Tackling the challenges of enhancing accessibility of Open Education Resources (OER)

A green and beige horizontal banner that says “ALT TEXT: don’t forget about me”.
Digital Vidya. (n.d). https://blog.inkforall.com/how-alt-text-can-be-your-secret-seo-weapon. Released under a Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial 4.0 International licence.

Written by

Brian Valionis, University of Southern Australia, placement student

Iain Wilson, Charles Sturt University, placement student

Steven Chang, La Trobe University, Coordinator Open Education & Scholarship

Sebastian Kainey, La Trobe University, Digital Discovery Officer

Content Warning.

Please be advised that this blog post references sexual and gender-based violence. If you or someone you know is experiencing violence or abuse, please call 1800 737 732 (1800RESPECT).


Context of student project

The project was part of a library student placement so students could gain “real world experience in contributing to the creation of an OER. It is to develop approaches for implementing alt text(which refers to captions that describe images) for the La Trobe eBureau book Gender-based violence and healthcare in Timor-Leste which is an OER to be published in English and Tetum (the national language of East Timor).

The value of the project is that it gave the library placement students real world experience in problem solving in an ongoing OER project. This was particularly valuable as it connected to Brian and Iain’s interests in how OERs can reducing educational inequalities.


La Trobe University eBureau

The eBureau was launched in 2016 with the goal of providing La Trobe University students (and the wider community) with access to high quality OER textbooks, this works in conjunction with the La Trobe Opal platform which is an Open Access (OA) research depository.

Importance of addressing violence against women in East Timor

The book is specifically for how East Timor health and allied health professionals can respond to domestic and sexual violence, an important resource as an estimated 34% of women in East Timor have experienced violence in their lifetime (Asia Foundation, 2016). It aims to teach health professionals what is sexual and domestic violence, its prevalence within society, how to recognise the signs, and how to appropriately respond.


Seobility. (n.d). https://www.seobility.net/en/wiki/images/4/44/ALT_Attribute.png Released under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International licenve.

Importance of alt-text and accessibility in OER

Alt-text refers to alternative text that explains an image, graph, infographic or other visual information through text. As argued by McGinty (2021) and Huntsman (2022) alt text is essential to enhance inclusion, as readers with a visual or other impairment may not be able to access the information in in the graphical material in the text. Additionally, alt text allows the usage of screen readers – software which uses audio to read out the text. This goes to Universal Design – ensuring that in the case of OERs and other textual works, the consideration of how all users can access the information of the text is a core component in creating it.

Challenges of putting alt-text in OER

These next sections will highlight the challenges that the team faced in creating alt text, through an honest discussion of the challenges faced the team hopes that others can see and learn from their problem solving.

Decorative images – alt-text required?

In alt text terms, decorative images refer to graphical components that do not contain relevant information, for example an image background or stock images. The design of the book is based upon engaging East Timorese reading culture and specifically includes images to break up the text into readable components. This means that not all images are going to provide relevant information, as such the decision was made to selectively provide alt text based on its relevance to the content.

Graphs

In normal circumstances alt text would describe the key and relevant information of a graph as per this example. However, in analysing the book the team noticed that the text already described the relevant data from the graph, so the approach was taken to describe the graphical aspects in relation to the key information.

Infographics

The challenge in creating alt text for infographics is attempting to reconcile technical limitations of screen readers which can cut off after 100-150 characters, to that of any accurate description being substantially longer than that limit. The team had advice from Nikki Andersen, Open Education Content Librarian at the University of Southern Queensland, to make alt text a separate section to accurately describe the image and the information that it contains. Nikki also provided the team with examples of how alt text could be created for infographics.

Specific example – infographic

In this book the infographics visualise critical components of key information. One example is the image below which shows the domestic violence cycle from page 27 from the book. As such it was highly important that this information be included and accessible to all readers.

Characters are depicted each stage of the cycle of domestic violence: honeymoon phase, tension building phase, threatening phase, angry explosion phase, remorse phase, pursuit and reconciliation phase

This is a proposed alternative text for the above image “Characters are depicted each stage of the cycle of domestic violence: honeymoon phase, tension building phase, threatening phase, angry explosion phase, remorse phase, pursuit and reconciliation phase”. This isn’t the final alternative text but rather an example of how the team made proposals in the drafting process.

Reflection and conclusion

The key lesson from this project was how alt text needs to be relevant and in context with the greater focus of the resource. As this example from Harvard demonstrates, even a relatively simple image will have differing focuses and meaning depending upon the subject of the greater text. In this case the focus in creating alt text was very much upon keeping the information relevant to the key goal of providing information about sexual and domestic violence for health professionals in East Timor.

Acknowledgment

The team would like to express their utmost gratitude to Nikki Anderson, her assistance and advice was invaluable to the team and the greater project. Nikki has edited an OER, “Enhancing Inclusion, Diversity, Equity and Accessibility (IDEA) in Open Educational Resources (OER) – Australian Edition”.

The team would also like to express their gratitude to Adele Walsh, Senior Coordinator, Community Programs and Engagement who organised the placement and learning opportunities for the students.

Reference list

Andersen, N. (Ed). (2022). Enhancing Inclusion, Diversity, Equity and Accessibility (IDEA) in Open Educational Resources (OER). University of Southern Queensland. https://open.umn.edu/opentextbooks/textbooks/1247

Asia Foundation. (2016). Fact Sheet 4. Sexual Violence against Women in Timor-Leste. Asia Foundation. https://asiafoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/eng-FS4-2016-05-04-screen.pdf

Huntsman. S. (2022). An Image for All: The Rhetoric for Writing Alt-Text. 2022 IEEE International Professional Communication Conference (ProComm), 61–52. https://doi.org/10.1109/procomm53155.2022.00012

McGinty. J. (2021). Accessible Digital Learning Materials for Inclusive Adult Education. Adult Learning., 32(2), 96–98. https://doi.org/10.1177/1045159520961470

17 thoughts on “Tackling the challenges of enhancing accessibility of Open Education Resources (OER)

  1. Feeling the exam blues? Let’s jazz it up with online exam help! Our band of brainy buddies is ready to jam, making sure your grades hit all the right notes. Toss aside the worry, jump into the rhythm, and let’s make some exam magic together!

  2. Jump in, and let’s turbocharge your exam prep! Our take my final exam for me service is like a rocket booster for your grades. We’ve got a dynamite team ready to launch you towards success. Drop the stress, strap in, and prepare for an academic lift-off!

  3. Each challenge is an opportunity in disguise. With our take my proctor exam for me service, unlock the doors to your potential. Our dedicated team sees the genius within you, waiting to shine. Embrace this chance to transform, to soar, and to redefine your academic journey.

  4. Remember those times when exams felt overwhelming? With our take my online test for me service, you can recapture the confidence of years. Supported by our seasoned experts, you can reignite that passion for learning and grasp the grades you’ve always yearned for. Let’s bring back those golden days of academic triumph.

  5. Think about it – why stress when you have a proven ally in take my proctoru exam for me? Our credentialed team is more than just a service; it’s your ticket to achieving those elusive grades. Leave behind the anxiety, embrace our expertise, and set yourself on a trajectory towards undeniable success.

  6. Once upon a time, in a world filled with exam worries, a hero named take my teas exam for me emerged. Armed with a team of scholarly knights, they set out on a mission: to banish stress and bring about a renaissance of incredible grades. Join them on this journey, and write your own success story.

  7. Got exams? No biggie. Slide into our take online exam for me service and let’s knock this out together. Our crew’s solid, and we’re here to make sure you ace it. No more cramming, just winning. Trust the process, and let’s do this!

  8. In the shadow of looming tests, a beacon named take my exam for me shines so bright. With mentors skilled and always set, guiding you through the darkest night. Let not stress steal your dreams away; our promise stands, come what might. In exams’ dance, you’ll lead the way, with results that truly delight.

  9. In consideration of the apprehensions surrounding online examinations, our take my test for me service proposes a systematic approach to alleviating such concerns. Employing a proficient team, we prioritize your academic achievements. Trust in our methodical process and anticipate exemplary results.

  10. In a digital age of evolving exams, our pay someone to take my online exam service is the innovative solution you’ve been seeking. With a team versed in next-gen tutoring, we guarantee an optimized learning experience. Embrace the future with confidence, and let us pioneer your path to success.

  11. In times of academic trepidation, our pay someone to take my exam for me service stands as a beacon of hope. Our seasoned cadre is poised to aid you in your scholarly endeavors, ensuring that you rise above in your online evaluations. Bid farewell to nocturnal study sessions and entrust your aspirations to us.

  12. Rise above the anxiety! With our pay someone to take my exam service, envision a future where those exams are but a stepping stone to your success. Our dedicated team is here to empower you. Believe in yourself, believe in our approach, and witness transformative results.

  13. Should you find yourself concerned about upcoming examinations, we’d like to introduce our esteemed take my exam online service. Our experienced team is dedicated to guiding you towards achieving excellent outcomes in your online exams. Ensure you’re well-rested by entrusting us with your exam preparations. We are committed to delivering exceptional results; now is your moment to excel.

  14. Get excited! Those pesky exams don’t stand a chance against our amazing take my exam for me service. We have a superstar team ready to guide you to victory! Forget the stress and envision the incredible results. We’re here, and we’re all about helping YOU shine!

  15. Hey there! Stressed about those exams? No worries! Our take my online exam for me service is here to help. With our amazing team by your side, you’re gonna ace those online tests. Say bye to those all-nighters and hello to fantastic scores. We’ve got this – you’re about to rock those exams!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *